What Does “Begging the question” Mean?
A Fireside Chat With ChatGTP
In its traditional usage, "begging the question" refers to a type of logical fallacy where the conclusion of an argument is assumed in one of the premises. It's a form of circular reasoning because the proof of the argument is already accepted as fact within the argument itself.
For example, consider the argument, "God must exist because the Bible says so, and the Bible is the word of God." This argument begs the question because it assumes the existence of God (which is the conclusion it aims to prove) in one of its premises, i.e., that the Bible is the word of God.
In recent times, however, the phrase "begging the question" has been commonly (and mistakenly) used as a synonym for "raising the question." For instance, someone might say, "Given the increasing frequency of wildfires, it begs the question: Are we doing enough to combat climate change?" This usage is considered incorrect by purists, although it has become widespread in casual conversation and even in journalistic writing.
To put it in clear terms
Correct usage: "His argument that I should trust him because he's very trustworthy begs the question."
Incorrect (but common) usage: "The growing income disparity begs the question: is capitalism working for everyone?"
While the second usage is prevalent, it's worth noting that it doesn't align with the original philosophical meaning of the term.
More Conversations with ChatGPT
